The Rogansphere – consisting of Joe Rogan and like-minded comedians orbiting around him – faces steady and consistent criticism from YouTubers (whose focus and most popular content is criticising the Rogansphere). Popular critiques of the Rogansphere began with Mike David/Redbar (at redbarradio.net), and he (and fans) uploaded clips of these to YouTube.
Today, the most impressive videos tackling the Rogansphere come from the channel The Elephant Graveyard (impressive because they’re long-form, documentary-style, and involve a lot of skilled editing work). Videos of his that are well worth a watch include ‘“Burn the Boats” is a Funeral for Joe Rogan’s Comedy Career’, ‘How Comedy Became a Dystopian Imperial Hell World’, and his most recent (and best) work to date, ‘How Comedy Was Destroyed by an Anti-Reality Doomsday Cult’. Other channels articulating all the problems with the Rogansphere include 2lazy2try, Podcast Cringe, Comedy Enforcement, and American Redact.
Well-known comics have also voiced the issues they have with the Rogansphere, including Bill Burr and Marc Maron. And political commentator Kyle Kulinski – who runs the political talk show Secular Talk, hosted on YouTube – regularly calls out Rogan too.
The critiques that YouTubers, comedians, and political commentators direct towards the Rogansphere often centre around them being cringeworthy, self-important, or out of touch; their shift to the right; punching down (using the most marginalised – often trans people – as the butt of their jokes); their obsession with so-called ‘wokeness’; embracing pseudoscience and conspiracy theories; grifting; climate change denial; spreading lies and misinformation; and praising (and buddying up to) Trump, JD Vance, RFK Jr., and right-wing billionaires like Elon Musk, Mark Zukerberg, Marc Andreessen, and Peter Thiel.
What I haven’t seen brought up enough (except by people in the comments sections of videos) is how Rogan (and others) made these disappointing shifts in their beliefs, attitudes, worldviews, and behaviour despite all their spiritual and therapeutic experiences with psychedelics. Rogan is a paragon in this respect.
share your toughts
Join the Conversation.
Great article, Sam!
One thing I would push back on a bit (which is possibly not what you were intending to say) is the idea that Left = Good / Right = Bad
I have met many great “conservatives” in my life, and many awful “liberals”. And vice versa of course.
I think we put far too much weight on people’s beliefs nowadays, and not enough on their actions. It’s very easy to hold all of the “correct” liberal opinions, while behaving like a manipulative narcissist.
Just my two cents.
Cheers!