Welcome to
Chemical Collective

Are you 18 or older?

Please confirm that your are 18 years of age or older.

You are not allowed to access the page.

I am 18+

EXIT

SALE NOW ON!

Do Psychedelic Experiences Present a Challenge to Naturalism?

By Samuel Douglas

By Samuel Douglas

Disclaimer: The views and opinions expressed in this article are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the official policy or position of the Chemical Collective or any associated parties.

Our psychedelic experiences often involve things that seem out of line with everyday reality. Sometimes, what we experience seems out of line with what is known by science. This potential conflict goes deeper than disagreeing with scientific knowledge or even the experience-reality distinction. It cuts to the core of the philosophy that underpins the idea of science as a way of learning about the universe.

What is Naturalism?

Naturalism is the idea that only things that are part of nature, in the broadest sense of the word, exist. Put another way, if something exists, it must be due to natural causes, not supernatural intervention, and follow laws of nature. By this definition, things like rocks, trees, humans, and all the things we’ve created are natural in that they arose from the natural world and are governed by things like the laws of physics. Things that are beyond natural causes, like a divine being that creates natural laws but is not subject to any of them, are not part of nature and cannot exist.

Historically, the philosophy of naturalism is associated with the rise of the scientific worldview, though there’s debate on whether one caused the other. Whatever the case, many philosophers argue that naturalism is the implicit philosophy of scientists and science.

There are varieties of this naturalism, which turn out to be highly relevant later. But since we’re talking about psychedelics, it’s worth looking at a strict form of it, such as the one supported by Chris Letheby in his 2021 book, Philosophy of Psychedelics. By Letheby’s definition, naturalism is as described above. But, he also takes this to mean that things like ‘disembodied minds’ and ‘any transcendent forms of consciousness not dependent on any specific brain or cognitive system’ are impossible (2021, p. 28). For Letheby, physicalism about the mind (p. 38), in that minds can only arise from physical brains or something like them, is acceptable, and cosmic consciousness is not (p. 30). Nor does he seem particularly impressed with panpsychism. By Letheby’s standards, the modern scientific worldview and naturalism are largely synonymous, especially regarding consciousness.

Are Psychedelic Experiences Compatible with Naturalism?

As with a lot of philosophical questions, the answer to this one is ‘it depends.’

What we take psychedelic experiences to mean and how we interpret them play a huge role in whether they present a problem for strict naturalism.

For example, I once took enough Salvia divinorum extract (back when it was legal in Australia) to have a full ‘breakthrough’ and experienced being outside of time. If I interpret this as an illusion, that the mental imagery was purely due to the chemical effects of Salvinorin A on the relevant receptors, and leave it at that, that’s completely consistent with even very strict forms of naturalism. My experience is still consistent with naturalism if what I experienced helped me understand the nature of time or, according to Letheby (2021), myself. If you believe that our experiences just purely come from our brains and molecules doing their thing, then it’s completely uncontroversial that chemicals that change how our brains work will change our experiences.

I’ll talk about more possible ways to solve or resolve the challenge below, but this is one way to make psychedelic experiences compatible with strict naturalism: just categorise them as not being real. If spirits, universal consciousness, oneness with the cosmos, shadow beings, non-duality, DMT entities, etc., are all illusions and we accept them as such, there is no clash with an uncompromising scientific worldview.

On the other hand, if I take my experience to be something more than just pure illusion, that my consciousness went somewhere, or that normal filters of perception were stripped away so I could perceive a more real version of reality, this presents potential challenges for strict naturalism. My belief that I really perceived outside of time and the version of naturalism that says this is impossible can’t both be true.

What do we do? Do we decide our experiences are pure illusion? Or do we discard science? Neither choice seems very appealing. Luckily, there are more (and better) options.

Liberal Naturalism

One way out of this is to be more expansive with what we take to be natural and the reasons for believing something exists. Depending on what area you’re looking to extend, you might come to adopt something like what’s known as Liberal Naturalism.

Liberal Naturalism isn’t precisely defined. Rather, it’s a group of philosophies that argue there are phenomena that can’t be reduced to scientific theories or properly investigated using scientific methods, but that are still real features of the natural world without being supernatural (Raleigh, 2022).

The basic idea is that what we can think and say is real might not only be what today’s currently accepted science says it is. As our understanding of the full breadth of reality grows, some things that science says are illusions or folk myths might turn out to be real. Alternatively, what we take from these experiences might constitute other ways of knowing, which are still valid; they’re just not science.

Under this proposal, you could say that something that strict naturalism ruled out, say, plant spirits or reincarnation, is still real and maybe even potentially discoverable by science. These things just aren’t described by today’s physics, etc., and they might never be.

Is all of this in line with current science? Probably not. Will it make some scientists and philosophers grumpy? Absolutely! But this is a way to make psychedelic experiences compatible with naturalism, without giving away your commitment to good science. All you need to do is admit that everything that exists is natural, but that science is not ‘the last word about what exists and the last word about what is known’ (Macarthur, 2024).

It’s important to understand, though, that Liberal Naturalism doesn’t automatically give you license to believe things that conflict with science. If you think the Earth isn’t round or that the Standard Model of particle physics is wrong, you’d still need to prove it!

Psychedelic Experiences and Scientism

Earlier on, I implied that there were multiple solutions or resolutions to this challenge. That was kind of disingenuous, as they all feature two basic moves: categorise the experiences in ways that don’t present a challenge for naturalism or adjust naturalism itself.

Of course, the biggest adjustment you could make to naturalism would be to discard it on the grounds that it’s just totally wrong. But I’m not sure that I could prove it to be totally worthless. If you make naturalism broad enough, it can accommodate almost anything, except things like a God that isn’t subject to any laws of nature. Even then, philosophers like Spiegel (2019) have tried to carve out a space for ‘near-naturalism’ that allows for such beings to exist.

Nor should we want to discard science. As a method for discovering certain kinds of useful information, systematic empirical observation seems hard to beat. But it doesn’t tell us everything that’s worth knowing, nor every way we can know it. Here are three examples of this:

Some important questions are about the ethical or moral value of some action. I can observe the effects of a drug on living things to the point where I can tell you everything about its positive and negative impacts. But that information, by itself, tells us nothing about whether it’s ethical to sell this substance for therapeutic use. Only other moral values, such as physical harm being bad or personal autonomy being good, allow us to make moral judgments on this decision.
There are also definitional or analytic truths that we ‘know’ without resorting to observation. Everything from ‘triangles have three sides’ to logical axioms like the principle of non-contradiction is a solid piece of knowledge we cannot verify using science.
Finally, there are limits to what we can observe, even using microscopes and telescopes. This is an enormous topic by itself. For now, it’s enough to know that the question of what science can say about the existence (or not) of things we cannot observe is open to philosophical debate.

I mention these things because they help us sketch the limits of science and see when it’s not staying in its lane. If someone tells you that science has proven that ‘capitalism is the best economic system’ or ‘God doesn’t exist’, they’re committing scientism: treating science as if it were the only true method to acquire knowledge, even where empirical observation is impossible.

Note that this isn’t quite the same claim as naturalism, that only natural (and not supernatural) things exist. Scientism is the view that what is real and what we can know are solely defined by what’s measurable using today’s science. What we see sometimes in this area is people using these terms interchangeably, even though the core claims aren’t identical.

From the perspective of liberal naturalists like Macarthur (2024), Letheby’s very strict naturalism contains a kind of scientism. A more overt example is when Zeus Tipado confidently declares on social media that there’s no such thing as DMT entities.

Integrating Psychedelics into Naturalism

To (finally) answer the question: yes, psychedelic experiences, if we think they’re more than just illusion, present a challenge to a strict naturalism that sees today’s science as the last word on how reality works.

But for versions of naturalism that don’t treat science as the only valid source of knowledge, the conflict largely disappears. We could still look for scientific explanations for everything we see and experience. If reality turns out to be bigger and weirder than we thought, or if some things are just inherently beyond science’s grasp, we’d be OK. That is the real challenge that naturalism has to integrate.

Samuel Douglas | Community Blogger at Chemical Collective | theethicaltrip.beehiiv.com/

Samuel is one of our community bloggers here at Chemical Collective. If you’re interested in joining our blogging team and getting paid to write about subjects you’re passionate about, please reach out to Sam via email at samwoolfe@gmail.com

share your toughts

Join the Conversation.

1 Comment

Inline Feedbacks

View all comments

Manuel

2 months ago

Volviendo de un fuerte paseo psicodelico tengo que dar una anotación.
La vida fue creada para sentirla, amarla y disfrutarla. Los psicodelicos me han enseñado lo que la vista no me dejaba ver, aprendizaje detrás de telones, debajo del agua, derritiemdome con la música.
Amo el mundo y lo que en el abita

9 minute read

In his book The Weird and the Eerie, cultural theorist Mark Fisher analyses the concept of the 'weird'. Sam Woolfe applies Fisher's analysis to psychedelic states.

09 Feb, 2026

Opinion | Psychedelics and Mark Fisher’s Theory of the Weird

Sam Woolfe

13 minute read

Un aperçu objectif du protoxyde d'azote, examinant sa normalisation croissante, ses effets puissants, son attrait, ses risques et son histoire.

07 Feb, 2026

Guides | Le gaz hilarant : Le protoxyde d’azote (N2O)

Nuit

13 minute read

Nuit compare les expériences de LSA issues de deux sources de semences, contextualisées par l'histoire et la science, dans le but de présenter une vision équilibrée des effets variables, des incertitudes, des risques et des enseignements de la LSA.

05 Feb, 2026

Personal Stories | Le LSA : la version naturelle du LSD ?

Nuit

12 minute read

Stroke, traumatic brain injury, and neurodegenerative diseases are leading, interconnected causes of global disability and economic burden with limited effective treatments. Sam Gandy highlights the potential of psychedelics as novel therapies to promote brain repair and recovery.

03 Feb, 2026

Science | Can Psychedelics Help Mend Broken and Ailing Brains?

Sam Gandy

11 minute read

The ancient, subterranean networks of fungi underpin life on Earth and are now emerging as a powerful foundation for future sustainable biotechnologies.

01 Feb, 2026

Science | Beyond the Trip: How Fungi Are Engineering Our Future

David Blackbourn

8 minute read

Dans la deuxième partie de ce guide sur l'influence du dosage sur les expériences psychédéliques, Eliacide examine les combinaisons de drogues et les expériences qui ne visent pas à dissoudre l'ego.

30 Jan, 2026

Guides | L’influence du dosage sur les expériences psychédéliques (Partie 2)

Eliacide

9 minute read

Eliacide explique que le dosage des médicaments est très subjectif et doit être choisi en fonction du niveau d'expérience personnel et du contexte souhaité, avertissant que les débutants doivent éviter les doses élevées et encourageant les individus à trouver leur propre « juste milieu » plutôt que de considérer tout conseil comme absolu.

28 Jan, 2026

Guides | L’influence du dosage sur les expériences psychédéliques (Partie 1)

Eliacide

9 minute read

Real-world data confirms the extremely low physical risk of psychedelics; the NHS and FDA intensify their scrutiny of clinical rollout; and we see expanding legal momentum in the US, as well as a shift towards shorter-acting compounds and even non-hallucinogenic, virtual alternatives.

26 Jan, 2026

All Articles | PSYCH NEWS – 26/01/2026

David Blackbourn

12 minute read

Nuit s'entretient avec Andrés Gómez, chercheur en conscience à l'Institut de recherche Qualia, qui fait le lien entre la science informatique, les récits expérientiels, les traditions contemplatives orientales et la recherche psychédélique.

25 Jan, 2026

Personal Stories | Mon échange avec le chercheur Andrés Gómez Emilson

Nuit

10 minute read

John Robertson offers a practical guide to understanding the causes of non-responses to psychedelics and what to do to move beyond them safely and effectively.

24 Jan, 2026

Guides | The ‘Nada’ Experience: What To Do When Psychedelics Don’t Work (Part 2)

John Robertson

7 minute read

Alfredo Squillaro argues that informed use, drug checking, and education are far more effective than stigma and repression in reducing the risks of psychoactive substance use.

22 Jan, 2026

Opinion | (Anti)prohibition, Psychonautics, and Designer Drugs

Alfredo Squillaro

11 minute read

Oli Genn-Bash reflects on the Western pursuit of an “authentic self,” using personal psychedelic experiences to question whether self-discovery is less about uncovering a fixed identity and more about cultivating a healthy relationship with the self that allows it to soften, open, and connect with others.

20 Jan, 2026

Self-Development | Discovering the Authentic Self Through Psychedelics

Oli Genn-Bash

9 minute read

Free parties can be understood as modern expressions of ancient ritual practices – akin to the Dionysian Mysteries – where music, dance, and psychoactive substances induce ecstatic states of consciousness.

18 Jan, 2026

Opinion | Dionysian Cults and Free Parties

Alfredo Squillaro

13 minute read

Nuit décrit son expérience du 2C-P comme un psychédélique puissant, à action lente et prolongée, appartenant à la famille des 2C-x – davantage comparable à une longue et exigeante randonnée qu'à un simple voyage.

16 Jan, 2026

Personal Stories | 2C-P : La charrette psychédélique

Nuit

11 minute read

Can psychedelics genuinely challenge and undermine the military-industrial complex by transforming consciousness, or do they risk being co-opted to merely help individuals psychologically adapt to an inherently violent and unjust system?

14 Jan, 2026

Opinion | Decentralised Minds: Can Psychedelics Undermine the Military Industrial Complex?

Oli Genn-Bash

11 minute read

Oli Genn-Bash explores the growing popularity of functional mushrooms, blending personal experience, research, and traditional perspectives to argue for a more holistic, respectful understanding of fungi.

12 Jan, 2026

Opinion | A Holistic and Spiritual Approach to Functional Mushrooms

Oli Genn-Bash

11 minute read

Despite bold promises surrounding psychedelics, a significant share of patients fail to meaningfully improve, revealing that non-response is a central – and often overlooked – challenge in psychedelic therapy.

10 Jan, 2026

Science | Let’s Talk About Non-Responders in Psychedelic Therapy

Ed Prideaux

8 minute read

Psychedelic use is commonly divided into spiritual, therapeutic, and recreational categories whose meanings are unclear and unevenly valued, with recreational use often stigmatised despite having aspects that deserve reconsideration.

08 Jan, 2026

Opinion | In Defence of Recreational Psychedelic Use

Annabelle Abraham

15 minute read

The Immortality Key builds a sweeping psychedelic-religion narrative on evidence that its own primary scientific authority later rejected as methodologically flawed, undermining the book’s credibility despite its popular success.

06 Jan, 2026

History | Psychedelic Bullshit? An Evaluation of The Immortality Key

Ed Prideaux

10 minute read

Over the past year, the psychedelic field has seen unprecedented scientific and regulatory advances collide with bureaucratic barriers and venture capital pressures, revealing both rapid progress toward medical integration and the fragility – and cultural tension – of an emerging industry at a pivotal moment.

04 Jan, 2026

News & Updates | PSYCH NEWS 2025 – THE YEAR IN REVIEW

David Blackbourn

8 minute read

Martha Allitt unpacks the history of MK-ULTRA, a secret CIA program that conducted unethical experiments with LSD, hypnosis, and other techniques in an attempt to develop methods of mind control and psychological manipulation during the Cold War.

04 Jan, 2026

History | MK-ULTRA: A Macabre History of LSD and Mind Control

Martha Allitt

16 minute read

Ed Prideaux examines Elon Musk’s alleged drug use and public behaviour in the context of his immense political and technological influence.

02 Jan, 2026

Opinion | High on Power: How Much Does Ketamine Explain Elon Musk’s Erratic Behaviour?

Ed Prideaux

10 minute read

Psychedelics can help us rethink the “hard problem” of consciousness by challenging the materialist view that the brain generates experience.

30 Dec, 2025

Philosophy | Psychedelics and the Hard Problem of Consciousness

David Blackbourn

12 minute read

Nuit décrit le 2C-C comme un membre subtil et apaisant de la famille 2C-X, qui évoque de doux souvenirs d'expériences sereines et introspectives.

28 Dec, 2025

Guides | 2C-C : la version Stone du 2C-B ?

Nuit

4 minute read

Theories suggest that N,N-dimethyltryptamine (DMT) is released in our brains when we die – but what do we really know about this potent psychedelic and its endogenous role in the human body?

22 Dec, 2025

Science | The Endogenous DMT Narrative: Separating Fact From Fiction

Stephanie Price

11 minute read

While psychedelics get most of the limelight in discussions about altered states of consciousness, such states can also be accessed through more accessible and potentially safer means, particularly sound baths.

20 Dec, 2025

Spirituality | Sound Baths and Altered States

Oli Genn-Bash

9 minute read

David Blackbourn explores the history and present-day use of psychoactive substances in the Middle East, including the religious, social, and political factors that have influenced this usage.

18 Dec, 2025

History | Contemporary Psychoactive Drug Use in the Middle East

David Blackbourn

8 minute read

Iboga, a West African shrub traditionally used in the Bwiti spiritual tradition, is now being used for microdosing in the West.

16 Dec, 2025

Personal Stories | Microdosing Iboga: Why People Are Taking Tiny Amounts of a Hallucinogenic Shrub

Martha Allitt

Our Products

Related Products

SALE! -35%

1V-LSD 150mcg Blotters From

(145)

1cP-LSD 100mcg Blotters From 18.00

(137)

Tryptamine Mix and Match Pack (4 x 0.1g) €65.00

(1)

SALE! -35%

1V-LSD 10mcg Micro Pellets From

(44)

SALE! -35%

1V-LSD 225mcg Art Design Blotters From

(62)

1S-LSD 150mcg Blotters From 29.00

(18)

1cP-LSD 150mcg Art Design Blotters From 25.00

(74)

SALE! -35%

1V-LSD 225mcg Pellets From

(26)

1cP-LSD 10mcg Micro Pellets From 15.00

(23)

1D-LSD 225mcg Pellets (1T-LSD) From 42.00

(13)

5-MeO-DMT Freebase From 23.95

(36)

1S-LSD 10mcg Micro Pellets €20.00

(3)

O-PCE HCL From 17.50

(25)

1cP-LSD 20mcg Micro Blotters From 18.00

(28)

1cP-LSD 150mcg Pellets From 25.00

(13)

see all products

Earn
Affiliates

Welcome to Chemical Collective.

Create an account to earn 200 welcome points.

create account

Already have an account? Sign in

Comment on an article

50

Check out our Community Blog and get involved with the conversation. You will be awarded 50 x ChemCoins for each comment up to a limit of 250 total ChemCoins.
Leave a product review

50

Have you purchased any of our products? Reviews and reports are so important to the community. Share your honest opinion, and we’ll reward you with 50 ChemCoins for each review!
Complete an order

X

Every time you complete an order with us, you’ll be awarded ChemCoins for each Euro spent.

Welcome to Chemical Collective.

Create an account to earn 200 welcome points.

create account

Already have an account? Sign in

Become an affiliate!

Earn commission every time someone makes a purchase through your link.

When you become an affiliate, you will be allocated a unique link to share with your friends, followers, subscribers, or Aunt Susan.

You can choose to payout the commission earned once per month, or save it up to receive on a rainy day! Commission earned is 5% of the total order value per referral.

Contact us to join the Chemical Collective family and become an affiliate.

Welcome toChemical Collective

Do Psychedelic Experiences Present a Challenge to Naturalism?

By Samuel Douglas

in this article

By Samuel Douglas

What is Naturalism?

Are Psychedelic Experiences Compatible with Naturalism?

Liberal Naturalism

Psychedelic Experiences and Scientism

Integrating Psychedelics into Naturalism

By Samuel Douglas

share your toughts

Join the Conversation.

Related articles

Related Products

Reward program

Comment on an article

Leave a product review

Complete an order

Become an affiliate!

Welcome to
Chemical Collective